First, when Carroll O’Connor played Archie Bunker, starting in 1971, he clearly played an middle- or even early wave G.I. (born 1901-1924) The guy looked smoked, somewhere (we Boomer (born 1943-1960) would have guessed) around 60. Yet O’Connor, age 46, was just barely a G.I. (last cohort, George Bush Sr’s birthyear). Now flash forward to this new show. Shatner, age 79 (first-wave Silent (born 1925-1942)), is actually playing the role of somebody younger, somebody age 72. (The new show is modeled after a wildly popular twitter site, shitmydadsays.com, wherein a 29-year-old relates 140-character epigrams given to him by his father.)
So, I guess I’m just amazed. These two shows are about the politically incorrect sayings of “old guys.” One appears nearly 40 years after the other. But the leading “old guy” actor of the more recent show is born only 6 years after the actor of the first. Wow. And Shatner actually looks younger now than O’Connor did back then.
Second, Stuever complains that Shatner’s character is much too tame compared to Archie Bunker and that the show passes up the opportunity to portray a tea-partying Boomer in his 50s today.
These are a couple of serious charges. Yet it would totally against archetype for Shatner—the very definition of a hip, postmodern Silent elder—to voice the gruff, hard, unenlightened, and unironic thoughts of Archie. And why not launch a show about Boomer culture warriors—right or left? The problem for TV drama is that this phenomenon is simply too serious and too central a part of America’s mood today to be treated in a light mood. With All in the Family circa 1973, everyone knew (and Boomers certainly knew) that Archie was weak, that his generation’s values agenda was toast, and that Boomers were taking over the culture. Therefore, Archie could be the butt of jokes. No one today believes that Boomers are weak in the culture or that their values-wars are unimportant. Americans of all ages are practically holding their breath. A funny, mocking TV sitcom about Boomer culture wars today would be like a funny mocking movie about the Great Society or the Apollo Moon Landing or the War on Poverty back in 1970. Simply unthinkable. Yes, one could launch a serious, well-reasoned critique of either. But no one would have considered it funny. G.I.s are supposed to build, Boomers to think. Those are the archetypes, and there is nothing to smile about. Reverse the terms (G.I.s thinking, Boomers doing), and sure you get a ton of laughs a minute.
An interesting generational take-off on All of the Family was That 70s Show—which was also very successful and ran for even more years. Red, the father, is (probably) a first-year Silent who fought in Korea rather than WWII. But he is very much a G.I. in nearly all of the same ways as Archie, though not with Archie’s really nasty edge. Red’s wife, Kitty, is also the G.I. female like Edith, except she’s smarter. The sadistic/pathetic moments between Archie and Edith are missing, which lightens the comedic effect. Red and Kitty’s next-door neighbors, Bob and Midge, are total Silent, with all of the outrageous midlife passages and youth-outbreak awkwardness (when they aren’t just playing the bland conformists) you would expect. The kids of course are all late-wave Boomers.